Suggestion Request to Add Alpha Tracking in the Trade Journal
Hi Team, First of all, I would like to sincerely appreciate the excellent work your team is doing on the Trade Journal. I believe the journal has the potential to become a very valuable tool for helping traders analyze their performance, learn from mistakes, and improve their decision-making. The continuous improvements and new features clearly show the team's commitment to creating a better experience for its members. I have a small suggestion that I believe could add even more value to the journal. Would it be possible to add an "Alpha" metric to the journal? In very simple terms: Alpha tells us whether we are performing better or worse than the market. For example: If my portfolio grows by 20% in a year And Nifty grows by 12% in the same year Then: Alpha = 20% - 12% = +8% This means I outperformed the market by 8%. Similarly: If my portfolio grows by 10% And Nifty grows by 15% Then: Alpha = 10% - 15% = -5% This means I underperformed the market by 5%. Why I think this could be useful: It helps members understand whether their trading system is actually beating the market. It prevents false confidence during bull markets when almost every stock is rising. It gives a clear benchmark to measure long-term performance. It can motivate members to focus on improving their process rather than only looking at profits and losses. Possible Formula: Alpha = Portfolio Return (%) – Benchmark Return (%) Benchmark can be Nifty 50, Nifty 500 , or any benchmark that the team considers appropriate. I think this would be a simple but powerful addition to the journal and would help members evaluate their performance more objectively. Thank you for considering this suggestion. Regards, Harshal Bare😊
Harshal Bare 9 days ago
Suggestion Request to Add Alpha Tracking in the Trade Journal
Hi Team, First of all, I would like to sincerely appreciate the excellent work your team is doing on the Trade Journal. I believe the journal has the potential to become a very valuable tool for helping traders analyze their performance, learn from mistakes, and improve their decision-making. The continuous improvements and new features clearly show the team's commitment to creating a better experience for its members. I have a small suggestion that I believe could add even more value to the journal. Would it be possible to add an "Alpha" metric to the journal? In very simple terms: Alpha tells us whether we are performing better or worse than the market. For example: If my portfolio grows by 20% in a year And Nifty grows by 12% in the same year Then: Alpha = 20% - 12% = +8% This means I outperformed the market by 8%. Similarly: If my portfolio grows by 10% And Nifty grows by 15% Then: Alpha = 10% - 15% = -5% This means I underperformed the market by 5%. Why I think this could be useful: It helps members understand whether their trading system is actually beating the market. It prevents false confidence during bull markets when almost every stock is rising. It gives a clear benchmark to measure long-term performance. It can motivate members to focus on improving their process rather than only looking at profits and losses. Possible Formula: Alpha = Portfolio Return (%) – Benchmark Return (%) Benchmark can be Nifty 50, Nifty 500 , or any benchmark that the team considers appropriate. I think this would be a simple but powerful addition to the journal and would help members evaluate their performance more objectively. Thank you for considering this suggestion. Regards, Harshal Bare😊
Harshal Bare 9 days ago
REFUND
"Hi Team, I just signed up yesterday and paid for JournalPlus specifically to use the FYERS auto-sync feature. However, the integration is not working and is incompatible with my account. Since I cannot use the core feature I paid for, please process a full refund for my subscription . ALSO I HAVE REPLY ON SUPPORT EMAIL support@journalplus.co BUT NO REPLY FROM YOUR SIDE SO PLEASE . REFUND MY FULL AMOUNT AS ITS IN 7 DAYS.
Dipak Rawat 19 days ago
REFUND
"Hi Team, I just signed up yesterday and paid for JournalPlus specifically to use the FYERS auto-sync feature. However, the integration is not working and is incompatible with my account. Since I cannot use the core feature I paid for, please process a full refund for my subscription . ALSO I HAVE REPLY ON SUPPORT EMAIL support@journalplus.co BUT NO REPLY FROM YOUR SIDE SO PLEASE . REFUND MY FULL AMOUNT AS ITS IN 7 DAYS.
Dipak Rawat 19 days ago
uploading trade from fyers not working
please help as your support feature still not working after 1 month are you scammer or what ? i want to upload my trade details on jounalplus but its not showing me any where .
Dipak Rawat 20 days ago
uploading trade from fyers not working
please help as your support feature still not working after 1 month are you scammer or what ? i want to upload my trade details on jounalplus but its not showing me any where .
Dipak Rawat 20 days ago
Situational awareness
In our community we have something like Green, Yellow, and Red for the environment. If the environment is Green we go full size, yellow test the waters, and for RED we don’t take any trade, keep ourselves on the sidelines. If I can add the situational awareness to every trade that would be great. While analyzing this will be really helpful.
seetaramhegde 27 days ago
Situational awareness
In our community we have something like Green, Yellow, and Red for the environment. If the environment is Green we go full size, yellow test the waters, and for RED we don’t take any trade, keep ourselves on the sidelines. If I can add the situational awareness to every trade that would be great. While analyzing this will be really helpful.
seetaramhegde 27 days ago
Losing streak
If you can provide a feature which shows the losing streak that would be great. We have a community which actually decides to go full size or small size depending on the portfolio feedback. If I am continuously hitting stop losses (that is called losing streak), if the number is greater than or equal to 5. Losing streak >=5 then we will stop the trading for a while. Could you please provide this feature somewhere on the dashboard and number should be configurable.
seetaramhegde 27 days ago
Losing streak
If you can provide a feature which shows the losing streak that would be great. We have a community which actually decides to go full size or small size depending on the portfolio feedback. If I am continuously hitting stop losses (that is called losing streak), if the number is greater than or equal to 5. Losing streak >=5 then we will stop the trading for a while. Could you please provide this feature somewhere on the dashboard and number should be configurable.
seetaramhegde 27 days ago
data
There are several errors in the Analytics section as well. Some calculations and statistics do not seem to match the actual trade data, so the Analytics results should be reviewed and corrected carefully.
Damian Wepfer 27 days ago
data
There are several errors in the Analytics section as well. Some calculations and statistics do not seem to match the actual trade data, so the Analytics results should be reviewed and corrected carefully.
Damian Wepfer 27 days ago
Completed
not round entry or exit prices
Please do not automatically round entry or exit prices. For Forex trading, exact price precision is extremely important for accurate risk and performance calculations.
Damian Wepfer 27 days ago
Completed
not round entry or exit prices
Please do not automatically round entry or exit prices. For Forex trading, exact price precision is extremely important for accurate risk and performance calculations.
Damian Wepfer 27 days ago
Trading Position Calculator
Hello, Can we create a calculator to calculate the position that can be taken on the capital and the entry and SL price and the Risk per trade?
Kamlesh Jain about 1 month ago
Trading Position Calculator
Hello, Can we create a calculator to calculate the position that can be taken on the capital and the entry and SL price and the Risk per trade?
Kamlesh Jain about 1 month ago
Completed
Request for Expectancy Metric Addition
Hi Team, Just wanted to gently follow up regarding my earlier suggestion about adding the “Expectancy” metric to the trading journal. I still feel it could be a really valuable addition alongside Profit Factor for understanding long-term trading performance on a per-trade basis. Would love to see this feature in future updates whenever possible. Thanks again for all the work you’re putting into improving the journal 🙂
Harshal Bare about 1 month ago
Completed
Request for Expectancy Metric Addition
Hi Team, Just wanted to gently follow up regarding my earlier suggestion about adding the “Expectancy” metric to the trading journal. I still feel it could be a really valuable addition alongside Profit Factor for understanding long-term trading performance on a per-trade basis. Would love to see this feature in future updates whenever possible. Thanks again for all the work you’re putting into improving the journal 🙂
Harshal Bare about 1 month ago
Noted on Calender
Calender feature is the best, however, please allow us to make notes on each day of calender. This is really helpful as we can write our observations for each day for a better review later.
Ankit Mongia about 1 month ago
Noted on Calender
Calender feature is the best, however, please allow us to make notes on each day of calender. This is really helpful as we can write our observations for each day for a better review later.
Ankit Mongia about 1 month ago
Intraday straddle sell
Do something for intraday straddle seller. It's difficult to trade log straddle. Very useful for positional also. Many people do this
Sandip Murkute about 2 months ago
Intraday straddle sell
Do something for intraday straddle seller. It's difficult to trade log straddle. Very useful for positional also. Many people do this
Sandip Murkute about 2 months ago
Completed
Request to Add Expectancy Metric in Trading Journal
Hi Team, I hope you’re doing well. First of all, I really appreciate the effort you’ve put into building the trading journal. The Profit Factor feature is very useful for evaluating overall system performance. I would like to suggest adding one more important metric called “Expectancy”, which can further enhance the effectiveness of the journal. What is Expectancy? Expectancy helps traders understand the average profit or loss per trade. It gives a clear idea of whether a trading system is actually profitable over time. Simple Formula: Expectancy = (Win Rate × Average Win) – (Loss Rate × Average Loss) Why it is important: It shows how much a trader can expect to earn (or lose) per trade on average It helps in evaluating if a strategy has a real edge Even with a low win rate, a system can be profitable if expectancy is positive It complements Profit Factor by giving a more practical, per-trade insight For example, two traders can have the same Profit Factor, but very different expectancy — which directly impacts long-term growth. Adding this metric will help users make better decisions and understand their trading performance more deeply. Hope you consider this suggestion. Looking forward to future updates! Thanks & Regards, harshal bare.
Harshal Bare about 2 months ago
Completed
Request to Add Expectancy Metric in Trading Journal
Hi Team, I hope you’re doing well. First of all, I really appreciate the effort you’ve put into building the trading journal. The Profit Factor feature is very useful for evaluating overall system performance. I would like to suggest adding one more important metric called “Expectancy”, which can further enhance the effectiveness of the journal. What is Expectancy? Expectancy helps traders understand the average profit or loss per trade. It gives a clear idea of whether a trading system is actually profitable over time. Simple Formula: Expectancy = (Win Rate × Average Win) – (Loss Rate × Average Loss) Why it is important: It shows how much a trader can expect to earn (or lose) per trade on average It helps in evaluating if a strategy has a real edge Even with a low win rate, a system can be profitable if expectancy is positive It complements Profit Factor by giving a more practical, per-trade insight For example, two traders can have the same Profit Factor, but very different expectancy — which directly impacts long-term growth. Adding this metric will help users make better decisions and understand their trading performance more deeply. Hope you consider this suggestion. Looking forward to future updates! Thanks & Regards, harshal bare.
Harshal Bare about 2 months ago
Setup / Mistakes Columns text/Tags aren't visible
Tags under the Setup / Mistakes Columns aren’t wrapping. Instead it is showing +2more or +3more tags based on the tags added in the respective column. Even though lot of space is available in that CELL.
Suresh about 2 months ago
Setup / Mistakes Columns text/Tags aren't visible
Tags under the Setup / Mistakes Columns aren’t wrapping. Instead it is showing +2more or +3more tags based on the tags added in the respective column. Even though lot of space is available in that CELL.
Suresh about 2 months ago
Not able to add multiple exits
I have multiple exits on the same trade. Please add option to add multiple exits on the same trade
seetaramhegde 2 months ago
Not able to add multiple exits
I have multiple exits on the same trade. Please add option to add multiple exits on the same trade
seetaramhegde 2 months ago
Need Help Section
Hello support, there is no “Help” section in Journal App. Could you please add? add FAQs and some video tutorials to understand how the journal should be used.
seetaramhegde 2 months ago
Need Help Section
Hello support, there is no “Help” section in Journal App. Could you please add? add FAQs and some video tutorials to understand how the journal should be used.
seetaramhegde 2 months ago